Who is Andy Williams?
Andy Williams is an American musician and professional wrestler from the Buffalo, New York, area. He was born on December 12, 1977, and became widely known through his work with Every Time I Die.
In professional wrestling, Williams performs under the name The Butcher. His imposing appearance and hard-hitting wrestling style helped him create a character that felt naturally suited to the wrestling world.
Williams began pursuing wrestling seriously in the mid-2010s. His professional wrestling debut is generally dated to 2016, and he later teamed with Jesse Guilmette, better known as The Blade.
His two careers eventually overlapped, giving Williams a rare profile as both a touring rock musician and nationally televised professional wrestler.
Andy Williams as The Butcher
The name The Butcher became Andy Williams’ signature wrestling identity.
Rather than building a character around elaborate costumes or comedy, Williams and The Blade developed a threatening presentation. The pair looked like old-school wrestling enforcers, which helped them stand out on the independent scene.
Williams has explained that the characters were inspired partly by the intimidating specialty-thug characters commonly seen in 1990s movies. The concept was designed around wrestlers who looked like dangerous obstacles standing between the babyface and the main villain.
That approach fitted Williams particularly well. His physical presence, beard and distinctive appearance made The Butcher immediately recognizable.
Andy Williams and The Blade
Andy Williams’ wrestling career is closely connected with Jesse Guilmette, who wrestles as The Blade.
The two began working together on the independent wrestling scene before eventually making the jump to AEW. Their partnership became known as The Butcher and The Blade.
The team first appeared together in 2017 and competed in several independent promotions before joining AEW. They were also associated with Allie, who performed as The Bunny during her time with the group.
Their partnership became one of the defining parts of Williams’ wrestling career because it allowed him to establish himself as a tag-team wrestler rather than simply a musician making occasional wrestling appearances.
When did Andy Williams join AEW?
Andy Williams made his major AEW debut in November 2019.
On the November 27, 2019 edition of AEW Dynamite, The Butcher and The Blade made a surprise appearance during a storyline involving Cody Rhodes. The debut immediately positioned Williams and Guilmette as dangerous heels.
The move was significant because Williams had gone from playing guitar in a respected metalcore band to appearing on national television as a professional wrestler.
His AEW career subsequently included tag-team matches and singles appearances, giving him an opportunity to establish The Butcher as more than a novelty act.
Andy Williams and Every Time I Die
Before wrestling became a major part of his identity, Andy Williams was best known as a member of Every Time I Die.
The Buffalo band became an important name in the metalcore and hardcore scenes. Williams played rhythm guitar and remained part of the group throughout its long career.
Every Time I Die eventually ended in 2022 following a highly publicized internal split. Williams subsequently devoted more attention to professional wrestling and later returned to music through other projects.
In 2026, Williams revealed that he has been working on a project documenting the history of Every Time I Die. He also indicated that a full ETID reunion does not currently appear likely.
That project could give longtime fans a different perspective on the band’s history and Williams’ years with the group.
Is Andy Williams still in AEW?
Andy Williams’ AEW status changed during 2026.
Earlier in the year, Williams said he was still under contract with AEW despite being absent from television. He explained that The Blade’s back surgery had affected their ability to work as a regular tag team. Williams also said he understood the booking situation and was waiting for the opportunity to return.
In February 2026, Williams publicly said that he wanted to wrestle for AEW again and believed he still had plenty left to offer. At that point, he had not wrestled an AEW match for roughly a year.
Later reporting stated that his AEW contract had expired in June 2026, making him a free agent.
Therefore, older pages that describe The Butcher simply as an active AEW-contracted wrestler can be outdated.
What happened to Andy Williams in September 2026?
Andy Williams is currently making headlines after a serious incident at an Enjoy Wrestling event in Pennsylvania on September 5, 2026.
Williams was wrestling alongside The Blade when his legs reportedly buckled near the end of their match. He subsequently collapsed and lost consciousness.
Enjoy Wrestling said that its medical staff immediately attended to Williams and administered CPR while waiting for an ambulance. The promotion then sent spectators home and canceled the remainder of the event. Williams was taken to a hospital for further medical attention.
As of September 6, reports indicate that Williams was hospitalized, but there is no reliable public medical update establishing the cause of the collapse or his current condition.
Some online reports have made claims about his condition that go beyond what the wrestling promotion and established wrestling-news reports have confirmed. Those claims should therefore be treated cautiously until Williams’ family, representatives or Enjoy Wrestling provide verified information.
Andy Williams’ wrestling career
Williams’ wrestling career is notable because he entered the business later than many professional wrestlers.
He began wrestling in his late 30s after already establishing himself as a professional musician. Instead of treating wrestling as a temporary side project, he developed The Butcher character and worked extensively on the independent circuit.
His early wrestling appearances included matches against established independent wrestlers, and he eventually became a tag-team champion alongside The Blade.
His national breakthrough came with AEW in 2019.
Why is Andy Williams called The Butcher?
The Butcher name reflects the character Williams created with The Blade.
The gimmick was built around the idea of intimidating hired muscle. Williams’ physical appearance naturally complemented the concept, while The Blade provided a complementary presence.
The duo did not need an overly complicated backstory. Their presentation focused on looking dangerous and functioning as powerful tag-team enforcers.
That simplicity helped The Butcher and The Blade become recognizable characters within AEW’s large roster.
Andy Williams after Every Time I Die
After Every Time I Die ended, Williams continued exploring both sides of his creative career.
Professional wrestling remained an important part of his life, while he later became involved with the music project Atomic Rule.
A recent 2026 podcast description also highlighted Williams’ transition from Every Time I Die to professional wrestling and then back toward making music.
His story is therefore unusual: he built a career in music, successfully transitioned into professional wrestling, appeared on AEW television and then returned to making music while continuing to wrestle independently.
Andy Williams’ legacy
Andy Williams’ legacy goes beyond his AEW matches.
For music fans, he is remembered as a guitarist from Every Time I Die and an important part of the band’s long history.
For wrestling fans, he is The Butcher, one half of The Butcher and The Blade.
His career demonstrates how professional wrestling can provide a second creative path for people who already have established careers elsewhere. Williams entered wrestling relatively late, yet he managed to reach one of the world’s biggest wrestling promotions.
His story also remains closely connected to Buffalo’s hardcore and wrestling communities.
Andy Williams: Wrestling and music career timeline
- 1977: Andy Williams is born.
- 1990s–2000s: He becomes involved with the Buffalo music scene.
- 1998 onward: Williams begins his long career with Every Time I Die.
- 2016: He begins his professional wrestling career.
- 2017: The Butcher and The Blade become an established tag team.
- 2019: The duo makes its AEW debut.
- 2022: Every Time I Die ends.
- 2024–2025: Williams continues making AEW appearances while also wrestling outside the promotion.
- February 2026: Williams says he wants another opportunity to wrestle for AEW.
- June 2026: Reporting indicates his AEW contract expires.
- August 2026: Williams discusses an upcoming project documenting Every Time I Die’s history.
- September 2026: Williams suffers a medical emergency during an independent wrestling event and is taken to hospital.
Final thoughts
Andy Williams has built one of the more unusual careers in modern alternative music and professional wrestling. Known first as a guitarist for Every Time I Die, he successfully reinvented himself as The Butcher and became a recognizable name in AEW alongside The Blade.
Although his AEW chapter has changed, Williams has continued working in professional wrestling and music. His planned project about Every Time I Die also shows that his connection to the band remains important.
Following his recent collapse at an Enjoy Wrestling event, fans are understandably concerned about his health. For now, the most responsible approach is to rely on confirmed updates from the promotion, Williams’ representatives or his family rather than unverified social-media reports.
Leave a Reply