The United States Men’s National Team (USMNT) fell just short of Gold Cup glory, losing 2-1 to Mexico in a dramatic final showdown. Despite taking an early lead, the Americans—fielding a largely experimental squad—couldn’t withstand the pressure from a more experienced Mexican side. As the curtain closed on the 2025 Gold Cup, we break down the key USMNT player performances in this hard-fought finale.
⭐ USMNT Player Ratings vs Mexico – 2025 Gold Cup Final ⭐
Matt Freese – 7/10
The NYCFC shot-stopper was one of the bright spots for the U.S. Freese made six solid saves and couldn’t be faulted for either of Mexico’s goals. His impressive tournament likely earned him a place in the 2026 World Cup squad.
Max Arfsten – 7.5/10
Arfsten had his best showing of the tournament. Winning duels consistently and staying composed in possession, the right-back was one of the top performers until his substitution in the 85th minute.
Tim Ream – 6/10
Veteran leadership was on display, but Ream was slightly off the pace when Raul Jimenez netted Mexico’s equalizer. A solid showing otherwise, but not his sharpest outing.
Chris Richards – 7/10
Richards got the USMNT off to a dream start with a clinical header. His 13 clearances highlighted a busy and mostly effective day at the back, though structural gaps emerged late on.
Alex Freeman – 5.5/10
Freeman showed composure under pressure at times, but he was caught out on both of Mexico’s goals. A tough learning experience for the 20-year-old.
Tyler Adams – 6/10
The captain brought passion and energy, but couldn’t fully control the midfield battle. A valiant effort, though the demands on him were immense.
Luca de la Torre – 6.5/10
Quiet but effective, De la Torre handled the dirty work in midfield. He didn’t shine, but helped maintain balance during key stretches.
Diego Luna – 5/10
Luna had a breakout tournament overall but couldn’t deliver in the final. A quiet, ineffective game before being subbed off in the 85th minute.
Max Tillman – 5/10
Tillman showed great hustle but struggled against Mexico’s dominant midfield. A relentless worker, but technically outmatched on the day.
Sebastian Berhalter – 6/10
His pinpoint assist on Richards’ goal was a highlight, but his involvement in the emotional scuffles hurt his focus. Still, he had a very solid tournament overall.
Patrick Agyemang – 6.5/10
The striker held the ball well and drew multiple fouls, showing promise as a target man. Still needs to prove he can convert chances at the top level.
Substitutes
Damion Downs (69’) – N/A
Didn’t have enough time to influence the match.
Jack McGlynn (82’) – N/A
A late introduction with minimal involvement.
Brenden Aaronson (85’) – N/A
Not enough time to make a difference.
John Tolkin (85’) – N/A
Had a brief cameo but little impact.
Final Verdict
Despite falling short, this Gold Cup run was an invaluable opportunity for the USMNT’s next generation. While some players boosted their reputations, others will need to regroup and grow. Mexico’s experience ultimately prevailed, but the future for U.S. Soccer remains promising.
