NY Giants Offseason Grade Highlights Jameis Winston Move as Key Bargain
The New York Giants may not have lit up the headlines with flashy trades or blockbuster free-agent signings this offseason, but ESPN’s Seth Walder has given the team an encouraging offseason grade—and pointed to one surprising move as their smartest decision.
According to Walder, the NY Giants’ offseason grade of a “B” reflects a strategic reset following a disappointing season. The franchise made several significant additions, but what caught Walder’s attention most was the signing of quarterback Jameis Winston, calling it the Giants’ best move of the offseason.
“The Giants entered the offseason needing a quarterback,” Walder wrote. “They acquired three. In free agency, they brought in both Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston for a combined $14 million in cap space. It was a good bargain.”
A Budget-Friendly QB Room With Big Potential
At face value, the Giants’ approach to their quarterback situation may look chaotic. They signed two veterans—Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston—while also drafting potential future starter Jaxson Dart in the first round. But instead of raising eyebrows, ESPN praised the tactic for its value and flexibility.
“Wilson raises the floor and Winston the ceiling,” Walder added. “Even though neither is the team’s future quarterback, why not try both at that cost?”
This calculated gamble gives New York a strong mix of experience and upside. While Wilson is expected to start Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season, national analysts are already questioning how long he’ll hold onto the job. Winston’s dynamic arm talent and past starting experience make him a viable option if Wilson falters. And lurking behind both is Dart—viewed by many as the franchise’s future.
QB Battle Brewing in New York?
Training camp will be crucial in determining the final quarterback depth chart. Winston, who has flashed brilliance but struggled with consistency throughout his career, is battling to secure the backup role over Dart. Reports from spring practices suggest Dart has already begun taking second-team reps, heating up the competition.
Winston still has a chance to earn meaningful playing time, especially if Wilson’s struggles from his Denver days continue. That uncertainty, while risky, gives the Giants a unique edge—having depth and options at one of the league’s most important positions.
Giants Not in Rebuild Mode
What’s clear is that the Giants aren’t treating 2025 like a rebuild. Beyond the quarterback room, New York made serious moves to improve the roster:
-
Added talent to the defensive line
-
Drafted superstar wide receiver Malik Nabers
-
Invested in young, athletic depth across both sides of the ball
These are not the moves of a franchise easing into a new era—they’re bold steps toward contention in the NFC.
Final Thoughts
The NY Giants’ offseason grade of “B” might not sound elite, but given their trajectory, it signals meaningful progress. The front office played the quarterback market smartly, securing upside without sacrificing future flexibility.
If Russell Wilson regains his form, Winston finds consistency, or Jaxson Dart develops faster than expected, the Giants could surprise a lot of people this season. For now, ESPN’s grade confirms it: New York made the right moves—starting with Jameis Winston.
