The Chicago White Sox have made a significant move in the 2026 MLB offseason, reportedly agreeing to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with right-handed pitcher Dustin May. The agreement represents a major investment in the 29-year-old starting pitcher as Chicago looks to strengthen its rotation ahead of the 2027 season.
According to ESPN, a source confirmed that the White Sox and May have reached an agreement worth $52.5 million over three years. The deal carries an average annual value of $17.5 million, making it an important commitment for a pitcher who has experienced both encouraging stretches and injury setbacks during his MLB career.
The agreement was first reported by FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray.
Dustin May Signs Three-Year, $52.5 Million Deal With White Sox
The White Sox have agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with Dustin May, according to ESPN’s November 17 report. The deal brings the right-hander to Chicago after he spent the 2026 season with the Milwaukee Brewers and St. Louis Cardinals.
May finished the 2026 regular season with a 7-9 record and a 4.70 ERA, recording 144 strikeouts. He pitched 145⅔ innings between the two National League clubs.
Despite his inconsistent results, May remains an interesting addition because of his age, pitching ability and experience as a major league starter.
Chicago is investing $17.5 million per season in the right-hander, showing its willingness to spend on starting pitching with potential for improvement.
Dustin May’s 2026 Season With Brewers and Cardinals
May’s 2026 campaign included two different stops after he was acquired by Milwaukee at the trade deadline.
He made 10 regular-season starts for the Brewers, posting a 5.65 ERA. He also appeared in five postseason games as Milwaukee advanced to the World Series and won its first championship.
May recorded a 5.73 ERA during those postseason appearances.
Although his overall numbers were not particularly impressive, his ability to remain in the rotation and accumulate innings was an encouraging development after several injury-related interruptions earlier in his career.
His 144 strikeouts also demonstrated that he continues to have the ability to miss bats against major league hitters.
Dustin May’s Career Statistics and Injury History
Dustin May has experienced several challenges throughout his professional career, particularly because of significant injuries.
Across eight MLB seasons, he has recorded a 26-29 record with a 4.12 ERA in 102 appearances, including 88 starts. He has played for the Los Angeles Dodgers, Boston Red Sox, St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers.
May missed the entire 2024 season while recovering from his second Tommy John surgery and an esophageal tear.
Those medical setbacks interrupted his development and limited his availability during important stages of his career.
However, he has managed to pitch more than 130 innings in each of the past two seasons. That consecutive workload represents an important development as he prepares for his next chapter with the White Sox.
His underlying pitching numbers have also offered some encouragement, even though his ERA has not always reflected the quality of his performances.
What Dustin May’s Contract Means for the Chicago White Sox
The signing gives Chicago another experienced starting pitcher as the organization continues to build its roster for the upcoming season.
At 29, May still has time to improve and potentially become a more consistent contributor. His experience with multiple MLB organizations could also help provide stability to the pitching staff.
The three-year commitment suggests that the White Sox see value beyond his 2026 statistics.
However, there are understandable questions surrounding the investment. His injury history and recent ERA numbers make consistency an important factor heading into 2027.
If May can maintain his recent workload while improving his results, the contract could become an important part of Chicago’s rotation plans.
Dustin May’s Contract Could Affect Mitch Keller’s Trade Value
Chicago’s agreement with May could also influence the Pittsburgh Pirates’ offseason decisions involving starting pitcher Mitch Keller.
According to FanSided’s Rum Bunter report, the White Sox’s willingness to guarantee May $52.5 million could change how Pittsburgh evaluates Keller’s remaining contract.
Keller is coming off a difficult 2026 season, finishing with a 5.29 ERA across 22 starts before a serious teres major injury ended his campaign in August.
He is reportedly owed approximately $18.4 million in 2027 and $20.4 million in 2028, leaving nearly $38.8 million in remaining commitments.
That represents an average annual salary of approximately $19.4 million.
Compared with May’s new $17.5 million annual salary, Keller’s contract does not look dramatically different in the current starting-pitching market.
Keller also has a longer track record of handling a full season. From 2022 through 2025, he averaged approximately 31 starts per season and recorded a 4.15 ERA.
Although his 2026 struggles created concerns, Pittsburgh could believe that his injury contributed to the decline.
The White Sox agreement does not automatically establish Keller’s trade value, but it provides another reference point for teams evaluating starting pitchers during the offseason.
Will the Pirates Trade Mitch Keller?
The Pirates must decide whether trading Keller would improve their roster or create another problem in their starting rotation.
Pittsburgh has several promising young pitchers, including Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft. However, relying heavily on young arms without experienced rotation depth could create additional challenges.
Trading Keller could free up nearly $39 million in future salary commitments. Nevertheless, finding an established replacement could consume a significant portion of those savings.
The Pirates also have offensive needs to address following Brandon Lowe’s departure into free agency.
For general manager Ben Cherington, the decision involves balancing payroll flexibility with the importance of maintaining a competitive pitching staff.
May’s contract could encourage Pittsburgh to reconsider Keller’s market value rather than simply attempting to move him because of his salary.
What Comes Next for Dustin May?
Dustin May‘s move to Chicago gives him an opportunity to establish himself with another MLB organization.
The three-year, $52.5 million agreement represents a substantial investment in his ability to remain healthy, provide innings and improve his overall consistency.
His recent workload provides some encouragement, but his 2026 performance also highlights the challenges he must address.
For the White Sox, the priority will be getting consistent production from their new starting pitcher. For May, the upcoming 2027 campaign offers an opportunity to demonstrate that he can deliver on the expectations attached to his new contract.
With the MLB offseason underway, his agreement is also likely to remain relevant to the wider starting-pitching market and other teams considering veteran rotation options.
Leave a Reply