Introduction
Amari Cooper has been a focal point in NFL free-agency chatter in 2025—with persistent rumors linking him back to the Dallas Cowboys, and speculation about potential interest from the San Francisco 49ers. Let’s delve into the facts, explore his career trajectory, and examine whether these the links to Dallas or San Francisco hold water.
1. Amari Cooper’s Career: A Quick Recap
-
Raiders & Trade to Cowboys (2018): Drafted fourth overall by the Oakland Raiders in 2015, Cooper was traded midway through the 2018 season to the Dallas Cowboys for a 2019 first-round pick. His arrival instantly transformed Dallas’ passing game.
-
Cowboys Performance (2018–2021): Over four seasons in Dallas, Cooper logged 292 catches for 3,893 yards and 27 TDs. His standout year came in 2020, when he signed a five-year, $100 million extension with $60 million guaranteed and posted career highs in receptions (92) and yards (1,114) NFL.comWikipediaDallas Cowboys.
-
Post-Cowboys Moves: Traded to the Cleveland Browns in 2022, then moved in October 2024 to the Buffalo Bills. With the Bills, he notched 44 receptions for 547 yards and 4 touchdowns in 2024.
2. Cowboys’ Past Decision: Letting Cooper Go
In 2022, Dallas opted to trade Cooper to the Browns for a modest return: a fifth-round pick and a sixth-rounder swap. Dallas used those picks to select Matt Waletzko and Devin Harper—but neither became impact players.
ESPN analyst Bill Barnwell later labeled that trade “the biggest mistake” the Cowboys made since 2020, comparing what they got in return unfavorably to Cooper’s production.
3. 2025 Rumors: Is a Reunion on the Horizon?
Cowboys’ Interest in 2025
-
In April 2025, reports surfaced that Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and front office were expressing “building team interest” in reuniting with Cooper, especially after failing to draft a wide receiver in the draft.
-
Analysts and fans echoed enthusiasm, with comments like:
“Playoff team with him,” and
“He doesn’t need to be as good as he was before… just have to be a competent WR2” The Sun. -
The discussion also reflected practical considerations: Cooper’s familiarity with Dak Prescott and his veteran presence could offer stability to the receiving corps.
49ers Rumblings
Some speculation also pointed to the San Francisco 49ers as a possible landing spot. With Brandon Aiyuk recovering from a significant knee injury, Cooper could fill a gap as a boundary receiver for San Francisco.
4. Can Cowboys Sign Cooper Again? What’s Likely?
A. Cap Space and Roster Needs
Dallas’ failure to draft a receiver in 2025 alongside acquiring George Pickens signals a need for veteran help. Jerry Jones is known for bold midseason moves, and Cooper’s established rapport with Prescott would aid immediate integration.
B. Value Considerations
Cooper’s market has softened—in 2025 projections estimated a two-year value around $37 million. Dallas might find a compromise figure that works for both parties
C. Alternative Paths
If the Cowboys pass, San Francisco remains a logical landing spot for Cooper given their needs; or other franchises seeking veteran WR depth could emerge as suitors.
5. What If…? Scenarios Unpacked
| If… | Outcome |
|---|---|
| Cowboys re-sign Cooper | Provides Prescott with a trusted veteran, boosts playoff aspirations. |
| 49ers sign Cooper | Adds depth opposite Kittle, covering for Aiyuk’s recovery. |
| Another team signs him | Cooper continues his career with a new chapter in a system needing a boundary threat. |
| No deal materializes | Cooper remains a free agent, pending training camp offers or midseason pickup. |
Conclusion
With all signs pointing to mutual interest, a Cooper-Cowboys reunion in 2025 remains plausible, backed by chemistry, urgency, and front office appetite. Whether the 49ers emerge as an alternate—and whether Cooper opts for Dallas again or somewhere new—is yet to be determined as the offseason progresses.
